Location Secrets: Why 87% of Coffee Shops Pick the WRONG Spot (And How I Found 30+ Winners)
Let’s Connect!
From Puerto Rican Coffee Farm to Multi-State Empire: The Location Strategy That Actually Works
By Brandon Ivan Peña | CEO & Founder, 787 Coffee
¡Qué tal, coffeepreneurs!
Brandon Ivan Peña here, and I'm about to share the location secrets that took me from a beautiful coffee farm in the mountains of Puerto Rico to 30+ thriving coffee shops across NYC, New Jersey, Texas, and back home in Puerto Rico.
If you're googling "how to open a coffee shop" or "coffee shop location strategy," you're in the right place. I'm going to give you the exact framework that built a multi-million dollar coffee empire - starting with the most critical decision you'll ever make: WHERE to open your doors.
The $47,000 Wake-Up Call That Changed Everything
Let me start with brutal honesty: 87% of new coffee shop owners pick locations based on emotions, not data. I was one of them.
Shop number 3. Beautiful corner spot in what seemed like the perfect neighborhood. Great foot traffic, reasonable rent, felt "right" when I walked through. I signed that lease based on gut feeling and Instagram potential.
I lost $47,000 in six months.
Why? Because I fell in love with the space instead of studying the customer patterns. The foot traffic was real, but they weren't MY customers. They were rushing to work with their existing coffee habits, not looking for an authentic Puerto Rican / Latino coffee experience.
That expensive lesson taught me the location framework I'm about to share with you.
The Brandon Revenue Multiple Framework (Nobody Taught Me This)
Through 30+ locations and plenty of expensive mistakes, I developed a framework that nobody teaches in business school:
The 3X-8X-12X Rent Rule
3X monthly rent = You're going broke (I've been there)
8X monthly rent = Real profits are possible
12X monthly rent = This is where coffeepreneurs build empires
Here's how it works: If your rent is $10,000 per month, you MUST generate $80,000-$120,000 monthly to be truly profitable. Anything less and you're just buying yourself an expensive job.
Example from my Texas location:
Monthly rent: $8,500
Target revenue: $68,000-$102,000 monthly
Reality check: That's 283-425 customers per day at $8 average ticket
Question: Can this location realistically serve that many people?
What Starbucks and Gloria Jean's Taught Me About Location Intelligence
Before I share my personal strategies, let me break down what the big players do that most coffeepreneurs miss:
Starbucks' Data-Driven Approach
Starbucks employs 20 analytics experts worldwide who analyze foot traffic, demographics, and economic forecasting to predict store performance. They achieve positive cash flow within 18 months at 85% of new locations using advanced analytics.
Their secret? Clustering strategy. They don't avoid competition - they CREATE market dominance by opening multiple locations in the same area.
Gloria Jean's Community Model
Gloria Jean's serves over 35 million customers annually across 350+ locations in Australia using a different approach: community coffee houses with local franchise partners who understand their markets.
Their advantage? Master roaster quality with beans roasted fresh within 24 hours and deep local market knowledge.
My 7-Day Location Analysis System (Not Just the Tuesday Test)
Most people do the basic "Tuesday test" - visiting a location on Tuesday to see real traffic. I go deeper:
The Complete Week Strategy:
Monday 7 AM, 12 PM, 3 PM: Post-weekend energy and patterns Tuesday 7 AM, 12 PM, 3 PM: True baseline business levels
Wednesday 7 AM, 12 PM, 3 PM: Mid-week consistency check Thursday 7 AM, 12 PM, 3 PM: Pre-weekend building energy Friday 7 AM, 12 PM, 3 PM: Weekend rush preview Saturday 9 AM, 12 PM, 3 PM: Weekend family and leisure patterns Sunday 9 AM, 12 PM, 3 PM: Relaxed community gathering times
What I Track During Each Visit:
Total people walking by in 30-minute windows
How many carry coffee cups (market penetration indicator)
Demographics and energy levels of foot traffic
Parking availability and usage patterns
Competitor customer count and average time spent
The $89,000 Market Saturation Mistake
Location number 15 taught me about market analysis the hard way. Beautiful space, great foot traffic, reasonable rent. I was confident.
I lost $89,000 in 10 months.
Why? I didn't analyze market saturation. There were already 4 coffee shops within 2 blocks serving the SAME demographic. The market couldn't support another premium option.
My Market Saturation Formula:
Count all coffee options within 3-block radius
Calculate total market size (working population + residents)
Determine if there's room for another premium option
Analyze what gap in service/experience you can fill
The Heritage Advantage: How Culture Became My Competitive Edge
Here's what changed everything for 787 Coffee: I stopped trying to be just another coffee shop.
Our secret weapon? We control our supply chain from our beautiful coffee farm in Maricao, Puerto Rico, to every cup served in Manhattan. This isn't just about coffee - it's about sharing our culture, our story, our heritage with every customer.
Location Advantages This Creates:
Cultural authenticity attracts curious customers
Farm story creates differentiation from chains
Premium pricing justified by unique experience
Community connection through heritage sharing
When I scout locations now, I don't just count people - I find OUR PEOPLE. Communities that crave connection, authenticity, and cultural experiences.
The Parking Reality That Kills Suburban Dreams
In suburban areas, if customers can't park within 100 steps of your door, you don't have a location - you have an expensive hobby. I closed one shop because I ignored this rule.
Advanced Parking Analysis:
Morning rush: Quick in-and-out parking needs
Afternoon workers: 2-3 hour parking availability required
Weekend families: Stroller-accessible parking essential
Real Numbers Analysis (Not Your Wishes)
Most humans guess. I analyze REAL data:
My Competitor Intelligence System:
Count actual customers at competitor locations during different hours
Track their average transaction time and ticket size
Calculate how many customers they serve per hour
Study traffic patterns for 30 days minimum, not 3 days
Example: I spent 6 weeks watching a Starbucks near a potential location. They served 47 customers per hour during morning rush, average ticket $6.20. That gave me real benchmarks, not fantasies.
Your Action Plan: The Location Selection Checklist
Before you sign ANY lease, complete this checklist:
✅ Revenue Multiple Test: Does the location pass the 8X rent minimum?
✅ 7-Day Traffic Analysis: Real customer patterns documented
✅ Market Saturation Study: Room for your concept identified
✅ Competitor Intelligence: Performance benchmarks established
✅ Parking Assessment: Customer convenience confirmed
✅ Cultural Fit Analysis: Your target demographic present
✅ Heritage Story Test: Community ready for your unique value
The Bottom Line
Location problems can't be fixed with better coffee, prettier Instagram posts, or more marketing spend. Get the location right, and everything else becomes easier. Get it wrong, and even the best coffee in the world won't save you.
Remember: Use the 8X rent rule as your minimum viability test. Spend 10X more time analyzing real customer data than designing your logo. Find humans who connect with your mission, not just humans who drink coffee.
Cultural authenticity beats generic convenience every time.
What's Next?
This is Part 1 of my 8-part Coffee Shop Empire series, where I'm sharing everything I learned building 30+ locations. Next week, I'll break down "The Money Reality: Why 73% of Coffee Shops Fail in Year 1" - including the hidden costs that destroy dreams and the financing strategies that actually work.
¡Dale You got this.
Let’s build something legendary.
Author Bio:
Brandon Ivan Peña is the CEO and Founder of 787 Coffee, with 30+ locations across NYC, New Jersey, Texas, and Puerto Rico. Starting from a family coffee farm in Maricao, Puerto Rico, he's built one of the fastest-growing authentic coffee chains in America. Connect with Brandon at soybrandon.com and follow the journey @soybrandonivan.
Let's get to work. 💯
Want the insider playbook that's helping thousands build wealth without traditional degrees?
Every two weeks, I share the exact strategies, mindset shifts, and real-world tactics that successful entrepreneurs use to create financial freedom—including interviews with millionaires who started with nothing but ambition.
Join 15,000+ game-changers getting the SoyBrandon newsletter. No fluff. No theories. Just proven methods that work.
[Subscribe free here →] Because your breakthrough moment could be in the next email.